 xref soc religion christian 21754 path edu!rochest!rutger!igor rutger edu!atho rutger edu!christian from rexlex fnal gov newsgroup soc religion christian subject arsenokoitai scrogg 3 messag-id date 20 mai 93 09 02 22 gmt sender hedrick atho rutger organ fnal ad net line 199 approv christian arami rutger cont dr jame deyoung 3 r scrogg robin scrogg built discuss predecessor suggest twist word scrogg believ arsenokoitai hellenist jewish coinag influenc awar rabbin terminolog the term deriv lev 18 22 20 13 lxx juxtapos arseno male koiten bed repres hebrew miskab zabar ly male yet believ paul origin term borrow circl hellenist jew acquaint rabbin discuss 180 14 it invent avoid contact usual greek terminolog 108 if true scrogg observ explain word appear greco-roman discuss pederasti patrist writer avoid it meaningless nativ-speak greek 108 scrogg take second activ word word object second differ boswel's learn discuss 107 yet scrogg understand gener mean li male narrow refer with preced malokoi cor 6 9 scrogg interpret effemin call-boi arsenokoitai activ partner keep malako 'mistress' hire occas satisfi sexual desir 108 henc arsenokoitai refer homosexu gener femal homosexu gener model pederasti it refer modern gai model affirm 109 thi scrogg's interpret term tim 1 10 the combin pornoi fornic arsenokoitai andrapodistai slave dealer refer male prostitut male lie slave dealer procur 120 it refer specif form pederasti consist enslav boi youth sexual purpos boi adult male 121 even seriou mind pagan author condemn form pederasti he instanc arsenokoitai cor tim interpret gener condemn femal male homosexu rom 1 consequ paul must pederasti mind 122 we paul contemporari model adult adult mutual sex relat ship 122 in relat term context contemporari ethic concern scrogg emphas point specif item list vice cor 6 deliber intend mean paul the form function catalogu vice tradit stereotyp ani relationship individu item list context nonexist he conclud paul care specif item list 104 both basi mean term literari phenomenon catalogu vice scrogg argu scriptur irrelev provid help heat debat todai 129 the model todai's christian homosexu commun model attack nt biblic judgment homosexu relev todai's debat thei longer denomin discuss homosexu weapon justifi refus ordin 127 reaction to the new interpret of arsenokoitai d wright in year posit bailei boswel scrogg closer scrutini perhap critic evalu boswel's view david wright in thorough articl wright point shortcom boswel's treatment arsenokoitai he fault boswel fail cite cite inaccur refer lev 18 22 20 13 church father eusebiu apostol constitut clement alexandria tertullian origen 127-28 boswel consid serious possibl term deriv form mean leviticu passag 129 thi term deriv clearli refut boswel's claim half word arseno- denot object gender second half -koitai the lxx male sleep male make arseno- object wright fault boswel's claim linguist featur term includ suggest parallel 129 though boswel claim compound arseno- emploi object arreno- emploi adject wright believ differ dialect divers no semant import attach differ form 131 wright believ compound second half verb verbal forc half denot object second substantiv half denot gender 132 it boswel's treatment earli church father wright take special issu fail cite sourc for exampl aristid' apolog ad 138 arrenomanei androbaten arsenokoitia basic mean male homosexu 133 contrari boswel's discuss boswel fail cite hippolytu refut omn haer 5 26 22-23 improperli cite eusebiu syriac writer bardensan the syriac term ident syriac cor 6 9 tim 1 10 133-34 next wright earli church father arsenokoitai parallel paidophthoria refer male homosexu teenag domin form male homosexu greek 134 sometim parallel occur threefold list moicheia adulteri porneia fornic paidophthoria arsenokoitai replac paidophthori 136 clement alexandria protr 10 108 5 cite second tabl ten command you kill ou moicheusei commit adulteri ou paidophthoresei practic homosexu boi steal 150 43 anoth occurr arsenokoitein commit homosexu exist sibyllin oracl 2 71-73 it wright observ word coin jewish pre-christian writer hellenist set repres or sib book 2 137-38 wright discuss arsenokoitai rhetoriu 6th drew centuri ad writer teucer macariu 4th-5th john faster 595 139-40 the bear idea homosexu intercours contrari boswel wright repli boswel's content term absent literatur homosexu denot 140-41 wright point expect writer prior centuri ad exist greek dozen phrase refer homosexu sourc didach acquaint paul's letter deliber avoid cite scriptur boswel neglect cite church father 140-41 boswel's treatment chrysostom draw wright's attent 141-44 boswel conspicu misrepres wit chrysostom omit refer assert patent untru chrysostom long uncompromis clear indict homosexu homili rom 1 26 boswel exagger chrysostom's infrequ term wright observ boswel signal fail demonstr arsenokoit patent denot male homosexu activ 144 it infrequ technic natur avail term paidophthoria clearli prevail form male homosexu greco-roman wright survei latin syriac coptic translat tim cor all three render arsenokoitai reflect mean homosexu understand arseno- object second half word 144-45 none primari version support boswel's limit conclus base wright conclud discuss observ catalogu vice literari form he believ list develop late judaism hellenist jew wrote clear condemn homosexu greek thi parallel increas concern moral philosoph homosexu indulg the term influenc lxx 145 writer spoke gener male activ male categor male sexual engag paid 146 if arsenokoitai paidophthoria interchang encompass 146 in summari wright seek arsenokoitai broad term mean homosexu aris judaism the view boswel scrogg limit term activ male prostitut pederasti support linguist histor studi next question wright posit william peterson after good stuff histor linguist studi thi includ symposium plato if doubt modern understand homosexu understood contemmpl time paul clear thing also review paul's lev18-20 nt 1 law fulfil 2 lev 18-20 univers chapter gener those ot longer hold true todai cultur stick 13 r scrogg the new testament homosexu phil 1983 86 107-8 independ conclus appar connect e a sophocl greek lexicon roman byzantin period 146bc ad 1100 14 see discuss 101-4 he thing paul's languag rom 1 26-27 128 but doubt see cautiou p zaa cor 6 9ff wa homosexu condon corinthian church? sblasp 17 1979 205-12 he observ moixai malakoi arsenokoitai jewish anti-gentil polem yet paul's wor vice list indic paul address real potenti abus ethic messag cite primit tradit rote 210 wright disput zaa' attempt associ term idolatri 147 15 on boswel's treatment rom 1 26-7 articl r b hai relat natur unnatur a respons john boswel's exegesi roman 1 jre 14 1 spring 1986 184-215 excel critiqu 16 d f wright homosexu prostitut? the mean arsenokoitai cor 6 9 tim 1 10 vc 38 1984 125-53 17 in unpublish paper henri mendel arsenokoitai boswel paul effect refutr boswel's claim philolog arsenokoitai he find mean gener male sex male 4-11 18 wright's endnot 148-49 list addit sourc church father 19 we notic tendenc boswel fail cite refer sodom sodomi apocrypha pseudepigrapha see j b deyoung a critiqu prohomosexu interpret ot apocrypha pseudepigrapha bsac 146 588 1990 437-53 20 in light claim boswel infrequ arsenokoitai point mean lack homosexu signific wright ask pertin philo josephu paidofthoria josephu paiderastia clement chrysostom former? 152 71 in articl homosexu the relev bibl evq 61 1989 291-300 wright reiter point paul remark origin extend ot ethic church 300 